When a loved one passes away, the will they leave behind can raise difficult questions or create unexpected situations. Sometimes, the terms of the will are surprising, such as expected family beneficiaries being left out or unexpected beneficiaries being included.
In Pennsylvania, challenging a will is possible, but it is not an easy process. Courts do not set aside wills just because family members disagree with the result or believe the will is unfair. A valid will is generally presumed to reflect the wishes of the person who made it, and a person can make a will benefitting anyone they want. To win a will contest, the person challenging the will must have legal grounds and evidence strong enough to overcome that presumption.
This article explains the basics of how will contests work in Pennsylvania, including common grounds to challenge a will: undue influence, lack of capacity, and fraud.
How a Will Contest Works in Pennsylvania
After someone dies, their will is usually submitted to the Register of Wills in the county where they lived. This process is called probate. If the Register accepts the will, the Register issues a decree admitting the will to probate and authorizing the personal representative to act on behalf of the estate.
Admission to probate does not always end the matter. A person with a legitimate interest in the estate may challenge the will. In some situations, a person may try to stop probate before the will is accepted by filing a caveat with the Register of Wills. In other cases, the challenge comes after probate, through an appeal from the decree of the Register of Wills to the Orphans’ Court.
The Orphans’ Court is the division of the Court of Common Pleas that handles estate matters, including will contests. A will contest is not just an informal complaint to the court disputing an inheritance or lack thereof. It is litigation. The court will consider evidence, legal arguments, witness testimony, medical records, financial records, and other facts depending on the type of challenge being made.
The most common grounds to challenge a will include undue influence, lack of testamentary capacity, and fraud.
Undue Influence
Undue influence is one of the most common reasons for challenging a will in Pennsylvania. It arises when someone pressures, manipulates, or controls the person making the will to such a degree that the will no longer reflects that person’s true wishes.
Not every influence is “undue.” Family members often make suggestions. Loved ones may talk about estate plans. A person may choose to favor one child, friend, caregiver, or relative over another. Those facts alone do not prove undue influence. Rather, in Pennsylvania, a claim of undue influence focuses on three key components:
1. Substantial Benefit
The person accused of exerting undue influence must have received a substantial benefit under the will. This usually means they received a significant share of the estate, especially if that benefit is unexpected or different from prior estate plans.
For example, if a longtime estate plan divided everything equally among children, but a new will suddenly leaves most of the estate to one person who was heavily involved in the decedent’s life, that may raise questions. A substantial benefit does not automatically prove wrongdoing, but it is one part of the analysis.
2. Confidential Relationship
A confidential relationship exists when one person has a position of trust, control, or influence over another. This may involve a caregiver, agent under a power of attorney, close family member, financial helper, or anyone who was in a position to guide or control important decisions.
The court will look at the actual relationship, not just the title. Did the person manage finances? Arrange appointments? Control access to the testator? Speak for them? Handle medications, transportation, or legal documents? These facts can matter.
3. Weakened Intellect
Weakened intellect does not necessarily mean the person lacked legal capacity to make a will, and it does not rise to the level of lack of capacity as described below. A person can have enough capacity to sign a will but still be vulnerable to pressure or manipulation.
Evidence of weakened intellect may include declining memory, confusion, dependency, isolation, serious illness, or increased reliance on the person who benefited from the will. The question is whether the person’s condition made them more susceptible to being influenced.
If these three components are shown — substantial benefit, confidential relationship, and weakened intellect — the burden may shift to the person defending the will to show that the will was not the product of undue influence. Undue influence cases are highly fact-specific, and the surrounding circumstances matter.
Lack of Capacity
Another common basis for contesting a will is lack of testamentary capacity. In Pennsylvania, the person making a will must be of sound mind. This does not mean they must be in perfect health, have a perfect memory, or make decisions that everyone else considers wise.
The legal standard focuses on whether, at the time the will was made, the person understood the basic nature of what they were doing. Generally, the person must understand that they are making a will, know the general nature of their property, know the people who would naturally be expected to receive their property, and understand how they want their property distributed.
This can be difficult to prove because capacity is measured at the time the will was signed. A person may have dementia, memory issues, or periods of confusion and still have moments of clarity. Old age, illness, or forgetfulness alone is not enough.
Rather, to succeed on a lack of capacity claim, the contestant needs strong evidence, such as medical records, witness testimony, unusual behavior around the time of signing, or proof that the person could not understand the basic decisions being made in the will.
Fraud or Forgery
Fraud is another ground for challenging a will. Fraud can occur when someone deceives the person making the will and that deception affects the terms of the will. Forgery can occur when the testator’s signature is forged by another person.
For example, fraud may involve lying to the testator about another family member, hiding important information, misrepresenting what a document says, or tricking the person into signing something they did not understand to be a will.
Fraud cases depend heavily on proof. Just like with capacity and undue influence, suspicion alone is not enough. The person challenging the will must be able to point to facts showing that deception occurred and that it affected the creation or contents of the will.
Fraud may overlap with other claims, including undue influence or lack of capacity. For example, a vulnerable person may be easier to deceive, or a person in a confidential relationship may have more opportunity to mislead them. The stronger the factual record, the better the chance of presenting a successful challenge.
Contesting a Will Is Hard, But Sometimes Necessary
Winning a will contest in Pennsylvania is not easy. Courts take wills seriously and generally try to honor the written wishes of the person who died because everyone has the right to leave their estate to anyone they want. A disappointed heir or family disagreement is not enough. There must be valid legal grounds to challenge the will and evidence to support those grounds.
That said, challenging a will can be successful when the right circumstances exist. If a will was created because of undue influence, lack of capacity, or fraud, the Orphans’ Court has the authority to review the matter and determine whether the will should stand.
At Russell Law, we help clients evaluate whether a will contest is worth pursuing, what evidence may be needed, and how to navigate the Orphans’ Court process. We have extensive experience with Orphans’ Court litigation that helps us guide you. If you believe a loved one’s will does not reflect their true wishes, we can help you understand your options and take the next step.
- How to Contest a Will and Win in Pennsylvania - June 23, 2026
- From Family Farms to Oceanside Shore Houses: Keeping Property in the Family Forever - April 7, 2026
